Evan Agostini/Getty
A juror in Ghislaine Maxwell’s sex-trafficking trial was questioned below oath on Tuesday about why he didn’t reveal his historical past of childhood sexual abuse on a jury questionnaire—and about whether or not it impacted his potential to be neutral within the case.
Manhattan federal decide Alison Nathan additionally requested Juror 50 about his handful of media interviews shortly after the British socialite's responsible verdict.
“I figured a little bit article a few juror giving their expertise wouldn’t be record-breaking or actually within the information in any respect,” stated the juror, who glided by his first and center identify Scotty David within the press.
Now Maxwell is combating for a retrial in wake of Scotty’s January media tour, arguing he by no means would have made it to the panel had he in truth answered the 50-question juror type used to weed out potential bias.
The juror was contrite on the stand, saying he by no means supposed to mislead anybody and didn’t mislead get on the jury for the infamous sex-trafficking case. He additionally testified that his prior expertise didn’t affect his potential to pretty consider the fees in opposition to Maxwell.
“This was one of many largest errors I’ve ever made in my life,” the juror testified.
“If I lied intentionally, I wouldn’t have instructed a soul,” he later added, and apologized for losing individuals’s money and time.
Scotty claimed that he didn’t understand he made an error on the jury type till a Each day Mail reporter peppered him with questions on it in a video interview.
“Did I simply mess one thing up totally?” the juror recalled considering. He stated he was “shocked” and didn’t know he’d missed a query asking if he was the sufferer of sexual abuse.
Nathan ordered the prosecution and protection to file briefings on the juror’s testimony because it pertains to Maxwell’s request for a brand new trial by March 15.
Final week, Scotty’s counsel indicated he would invoke his Fifth Modification proper in opposition to self-incrimination on the listening to, and prosecutors indicated they have been making an software to grant him immunity for his testimony. By Tuesday, the Division of Justice granted that request.
The juror made headlines quickly after Maxwell was discovered responsible.
In late December, Maxwell was convicted of aiding her ex-boyfriend Jeffrey Epstein’s underage intercourse ring within the Nineteen Nineties and early 2000s. 4 victims took the stand on the high-profile legal trial and claimed Maxwell groomed them for the multimillionaire predator and typically participated within the sexual abuse herself. Jurors deliberated for six days earlier than discovering Maxwell responsible on 5 of six fees associated to little one intercourse trafficking.
Days after the decision, attorneys for the 60-year-old British socialite argued the decision was in jeopardy due to Scotty’s statements within the press.
The Unbiased, the primary to publish a function on Scotty, revealed the 35-year-old Manhattanite was himself a survivor of childhood sexual abuse—a reality unknown to the court docket as a result of he didn’t disclose it on his jury questionnaire. “This verdict is for all of the victims,” Scotty instructed the U.Okay.-based outlet. “For many who testified, for many who got here ahead and for many who haven’t come ahead. I’m glad that Maxwell has been held accountable.” The publication added that Scotty’s fellow jurors “went useless silent” when he shared he was a sufferer of sexual abuse and argued that survivors can misremember small particulars a few traumatic occasion, however not the entire of a traumatic reminiscence.
“I do know what occurred once I was sexually abused. I keep in mind the colour of the carpet, the partitions. A few of it may be replayed like a video,” Scotty instructed The Unbiased. “However I can’t keep in mind all the main points, there are some issues that run collectively.”
Scotty additionally granted interviews to the Each day Mailand Reuters, saying he didn't recall whether or not the pre-trial jury questionnaire requested potential panelists whether or not they had been victims of sexual assault and that he “flew by means of” the listing of queries. He stated that when fellow jurors questioned the accuracy of the accusers’ reminiscences, he swayed a few of them by speaking about his personal expertise with sexual abuse.
In court docket on Tuesday, Nathan warned the juror: “You have to reply my questions right now. You have to reply in truth. If you happen to do not reply in truth, you would be prosecuted for perjury.”
She additionally instructed Scotty to not share something about what jurors mentioned within the deliberation room.
After he swore to inform the reality, the juror reviewed Query 48 on the jury questionnaire, which requested if he had been the sufferer of sexual harassment, abuse or assault. Requested if his reply was correct, he answered, “No, it isn't.” The response ought to have been sure, he stated.
The juror stated he was abused when he was 9 and 10 years outdated however didn’t disclose what occurred till highschool. He testified that his mom reported the alleged crime to police however nobody was charged.
Scotty additionally addressed Query 25, which requested whether or not he had ever been the sufferer of against the law. He had answered no. “Wanting again at it now… it is an incorrect reply,” the juror stated. He stated that on the time, he imagined the query referred to being robbed or mugged. “I wasn't considering of my sexual abuse,” he added.
The juror later stated, “I don’t actually take into consideration my abuse a lot anymore as a result of it does not outline me.”
The juror then repeated one thing he instructed information reporters weeks in the past: “I flew by means of the questionnaire.”
Certainly, Scotty stated he by no means thought he'd be chosen for the 12-member jury out of almost 700 potential panelists.
When he crammed out the questionnaire, he stated, he was seated at a desk the place individuals dropped off their kinds. He stated the atmosphere was noisy and “super-distracting” and he “skimmed” the doc to get it over with, having waited three hours for an tutorial video. A breakup with an ex was additionally occupying his thoughts and focus, he stated.
“I didn't hope to serve on this jury,” he testified. “However for those who’re going to serve jury responsibility it would as nicely be one thing that is fascinating. However I didn't got down to get on this jury.”
The juror clarified afterward within the questioning, “That is one thing fascinating. It’s not like... a fraud case [that] may be boring. I simply felt like this may be one thing fascinating that retains my consideration.”
He stated he felt strain to finish the jury questionnaire shortly and in contrast it to taking a check in class; he stated he did not wish to be the final one to complete.
When Nathan requested whether or not the juror approached filling out the shape “with diligence,” he answered no.
Nathan additionally leveled follow-up questions after Scotty stated he didn’t inform family and friends about his previous abuse, asking why he instructed the worldwide information media.
“I solely used it with the intention to speak to a reporter about jury deliberations … why I imagine a sure manner based mostly on all of the proof that was supplied throughout trial,” he stated.
He additionally stated that he was impressed by the victims who testified at trial and have been “courageous sufficient to provide their story.”
“I felt like if they'll do it, then so can I.”
On Jan. 5, the prosecution and protection every filed letters with the court docket about Scotty’s talks with reporters, which raised questions as as to whether he was neutral at trial. “Whereas the Court docket instructed jurors that they have been free to debate their jury service with anybody of their selecting, a few of the statements, as associated within the media, benefit consideration by the Court docket,” wrote the federal government, which instructed the decide examine.
Maxwell’s attorneys argued that Scotty’s feedback warranted a brand new trial. “Ms. Maxwell additionally suggests that each one the deliberating jurors will have to be examined, to not impeach the decision, however to guage the Juror’s conduct,” the protection wrote.
On Jan. 19, Maxwell’s group filed a movement for a brand new trial which argued that Scotty’s false solutions on the questionnaire “resulted in a jury that was not truthful and neutral, and disadvantaged Ms. Maxwell of her constitutional proper to trial by jury.” Had he in truth crammed out the shape, they argued, he would have been excluded from the panel.
However Juror 50 might not have been alone in allegedly glossing over sure questions.
The New York Instances interviewed a second juror, who stated that they’d skilled childhood sexual abuse however didn’t say so on the questionnaire. “This juror, who requested anonymity, stated that they, too, had mentioned the expertise throughout deliberations and that the revelation had appeared to assist form the jury’s discussions,” the Instances reported.
“So far, this juror has not publicly revealed their identification, and Ms. Maxwell doesn't know who it's,” the heiress’ attorneys wrote of their movement.
“For its half, this Court docket expressed ‘confidence’ that its voir dire course of would ‘smoke out’ a juror who was dishonest,” they added. “Ms. Maxwell relied on the Court docket’s course of. And the Court docket and the events relied on the presumption to which everyone seems to be entitled: that potential jurors would rigorously and actually interact in voir dire.
“Sadly, we now know that Juror No. 50 (and at the least one different juror) didn't honor their obligations to provide ‘solely truthful solutions.’”
Whereas Nathan denied Maxwell’s preliminary request for a retrial and to query the opposite jurors, she did comply with query Scotty at a particular listening to.
“To be clear, the potential impropriety is just not that somebody with a historical past of sexual abuse might have served on the jury,” Nathan wrote in her ruling. “Fairly, it's the potential failure to reply in truth to questions in the course of the jury choice course of that requested for that materials info in order that any potential bias might be explored.”