Michael Nicholson is likely to be getting again in contact with the SFA after but extra VAR controversy involving Celtic. The Parkhead chief government revealed on the membership’s AGM that they contacted the authorities after Michael Smith’s handball for Hearts towards the champions wasn’t checked.
That was on the opening weekend of the know-how being launched into the Scottish Premiership and Ange Postecoglou was left scratching his head as to why Steven McLean, in entrance of the monitor on the Clydesdale Home base, didn’t refer match referee Nick Walsh to test it out. And the Celtic boss highlighted the incident after his staff’s win over Dundee United to point out the inconsistency after a contentious resolution.
Walsh was once more concerned after one other contentious handball resolution with the whistler this time within the operations room when he requested David Dickinson to have a look at an incident involving Alexandro Bernabei when the ball struck his arm from Steven Fletcher’s header within the win over Dundee United. Dickinson checked out it and pointed to the spot with Fletcher dusting himself right down to convert from 12 yards and cancel out the primary of Sead Haksabanovic’s two targets. And to rub salt into Celtic’s wounds, Argentinian Bernabei was booked regardless of understanding little about it together with his again turned when the ball hit his arm. It didn’t have an effect on the end result ultimately because the champions produced a late present to win 4-2 however it was nonetheless a serious speaking level. Right here’s what the pundits needed to say on Bernabei’s handball.
Packie Bonner
The Celtic goalkeeping legend centered on the definition of a participant's hand being in an unnatural place.
"The interpretation of the handball rule is the bit we're all involved about. If VAR is just there to provide a call whether or not it hit is hand or not then somebody has to interpret because it an unnatural place. It wasn't in an unnatural place as a result of he goes to go the ball and it is flicked simply away from him so he is utilizing his arms to get top. His hand is behind his again. He has no thought the place the ball is or if there is a participant behind him. He is received no concept that Steven Fletcher goes to go that ball in the direction of his hand. It is not, for me, in an unnatural place for a participant who tries to go the ball that he makes use of his arms for momentum. Alexandro Bernabei was booked. For what? Deliberate handball."
Rory Loy
The ex Rangers man backed Ange Postecoglou over requires consistency after Celtic weren't awarded a spot kick for Michael Smith's current handball
" Ange Postecoglou is totally proper to focus on the one at Tynecastle and this one right here. How are you going to give one however not the opposite? It defies logic at occasions. VAR are getting concerned in far too many choices that are not clear and apparent in the meanwhile and that is what's making it tough. Ange Postecoglou can be proper when he says that in the meanwhile if it hits your hand within the field then it is a penalty however there is a huge distinction between teething points and referees getting selections improper. Teething points can be the communication and the precise technical facet of issues. I do not really feel for a referee who will get the possibility to see an incident stay and 6 angles and STILL makes the improper resolution."
Michael Stewart
The previous Scotland midfielder was left perplexed on the resolution and is adamant the defender's hand was in a pure place.
"His arm is up there due to the best way he jumped. It’s not a penalty. That’s the legislation. They don’t perceive the legislation, they see an arm is on the market and it’s received to be a penalty kick. The legislation explains fairly clearly that’s not a penalty kick. I don’t care if the officers deemed it a penalty kick or not, I’ve simply defined the legislation, inform me how that’s a penalty?"
However did go on to accuse Ange Postecoglou of double requirements over his Hearts handball stance
"I've received loads of respect for Ange Postecoglou however he talks about consistency. Virtually to a person, Celtic have been claiming the handball at Tynecastle was a penalty kick. If you happen to're searching for consistency then I am undecided they'll say it wasn't a handball as we speak. I've persistently stated it is not handball given that it is not deliberate and their hand is ready which is pure due to the motion of the physique. You'll be able to't decide and select. Most individuals are saying the one at Tynecastle ought to have been a penalty however as we speak they're asking the way it's a penalty."
Steven Thompson
The previous Scotland striker was adamant it was a penalty - a view that left Michael Stewart dumbfounded and questioning if he knew the foundations.
"I feel it is a penalty. I do know he cannot do something and he cannot see it however does it must be consider to be a handball? The header is occurring goal. Handball within the field - penalty."
Leanne Crichton
The previous Scotland worldwide midfielder and present Motherwell participant did not really feel it was a spot kick however tried to see it by the referee's eyes.
"For me, it is not a penalty. His arm is barely prolonged out from the physique. It could possibly be marginal if it was on the t-shirt line and it comes off the best arm. (However) the legal guidelines of the sport say that if a participant handles the ball and denies a possibility at objective. That is how the referee will need to have seen it. He is denied a shot on course and that is why he is booked Bernabei. (As) he is stopped a promising assault."
Stuart Kettlewell
The previous Ross County boss expects his verdict to be unpopular however he thinks the match officers received it proper.
"It is extremely harsh however I feel it's (a penalty), I do. He does not know something about it, the ball comes on, I simply really feel his arm is outstretched from the physique that is what officers are . You will note this sort of factor being given as a penalty in Scotland within the coming weeks. The ball is travelling in the direction of objective, you do not know if it will go in. Lots of people are speaking about it being a pure place, I do not really feel it's when it is that far behind his again. His arm is sort of stretched straight out from his physique."
Marvin Bartley
And he was backed up the Livingston No.2
"I agree with Stuart. I do not assume he is aware of a lot about it, it is extremely harsh, I simply do not assume it is a pure place for his arm to be in, regards to going for a header or not. The referee and VAR sort of make the best resolution with that one. I might be extremely annoyed if that was towards Livingston."
READ NEXT