Megan Briggs/Getty
By some metrics, Tua Tagovailoa is having a breakout season.
The Miami Dolphins quarterback has thrived beneath first-year head coach Mike McDaniel, with highlights for what at the very least lately appeared like a playoff-bound squad together with a six-touchdown torching of the Ravens. Extensive receiver Tyreek Hill, the premier offseason acquisition, added an explosive factor to the offense, and McDaniel appeared like a possible coach of the 12 months candidate.
However when McDaniel confirmed on Wednesday that Tagovailoa had suffered at the very least his second concussion of the season—and completed the sport on Sunday anyway—the main target returned squarely to participant security.
And this time, McDaniel and the NFL have an even bigger drawback on their arms.
Tagovailoa was concussed at the very least as soon as earlier this season throughout a stretch that noticed him collapse to the bottom after taking a brutal hit throughout a recreation towards the Payments—solely to be hospitalized after one other thrashing days later, towards the Bengals. Within the first case, the NFL decided its protocol for concussions was adopted, however the league and gamers union agreed to revise the protocol to rule out gamers who expertise “ataxia”—stability and coordination points—even when it’s not clear they stem from a head harm.
Tagovailoa’s fingers may very well be seen seizing up after he sustained a head harm within the second quarter towards the Bengals on Sept. 29.
Sam Greene/Cincinnati Enquirer by way of USA TODAY NETWORK
The union additionally fired an impartial neurologist concerned in clearing Tagovailoa to play the second half of the Payments recreation. One drawback with that being the one head to roll: The ultimate arbiter in gamers returning to video games is a crew physician, not the impartial marketing consultant.
When it was introduced that Tagovailoa had re-entered the concussion protocol after a dropping effort towards the Packers this Sunday, the response from sports activities pundits, trauma specialists, and ex-NFL gamers was overwhelming. A number of argued he shouldn't play once more this season; some advised he ought to by no means play once more, interval—that the dangers to his well being long-term had been too nice. And at the very least just a few pointed to the play by which they imagine Tagovailoa clearly had his head slammed to the bottom within the second quarter, asking why neither the crew, nor spotters the NFL says are watching out for accidents, took discover.
“Tua Tagovailoa shouldn’t play any extra this season if the NFL is critical about well being and security and concussions,” Booger McFarland, an ex-player and commentator for ESPN, mentioned on a community that isn't recognized for holding league bosses’ toes to the hearth.
“[N]o physician of their proper thoughts can clear him this 12 months. Season over,” wrote Dr. Chris Nowinski, the neuroscientist who fumed in September that Dolphins’ workers and coaches “ought to go to jail” for letting Tagovailoa play towards the Bengals, 5 days after struggling the earlier harm he believes they “coated up.”
Now that the second concussion has been confirmed, one may assume the crew and the league are itching to take significant new steps towards participant security. That very a lot stays to be seen.
McDaniel, on Wednesday, advised he had no drawback with Tagovailoa enjoying once more—although he mentioned a lot of the proper issues, indicating he would observe the recommendation of medical specialists, and declaring that his participant is, in reality, a human being. And it could be that Tagovailoa confirmed no signs of a concussion throughout the recreation, the ostensible purpose he was allowed to complete it. (He had a brutal fourth quarter, throwing three interceptions, although it was not clear when, exactly, he suffered the concussion.)
Maybe extra noteworthy than a coach wanting his participant again: a league that appears unable to do greater than nitpick at its personal guidelines.
On Wednesday, the NFL introduced it was conducting a contemporary probe of the most recent head harm, in live performance with the gamers union. This may increasingly effectively produce some type of coverage change. The league would seem to have already admitted that is crucial when Allen Sills, chief NFL medical officer, mentioned Tuesday that every one related protocols had been adopted—and that Tagovailoa confirmed no signs of a concussion throughout a recreation by which he did, in reality, undergo one.
As neurosurgeon and ex-neurotrauma marketing consultant to NFL gamers Dr. Uzma Samadani wrote for The Each day Beast earlier this season, there are possible higher methods to measure head accidents than those the league is utilizing. However the mechanics of its evolving exams and protocols apart, the NFL faces a obtrusive drawback. Its personal Corridor of Famer pundits are saying one thing is horribly improper. If Tagovailoa does return—this weekend or later—and the Dolphins go on some type of a playoff run, the story won't be that his expertise overcame obstacles. Or at the very least not solely that.
It would even be that a resounding refrain, of ex-players and specialists, crying out in alarm had been ignored.