5 big Willie Collum calls in Hibs vs Rangers analysed as referee in the spotlight after fiery encounter

The Scottish Premiership has an uncanny knack to offer the thrills and Saturday's pulsating 2-2 draw between Hibs and Rangers had a little bit little bit of every thing.

Full dedication and cracking targets is what punters search and the lunchtime showdown in Leith was jam-packed with main speaking factors. Referee Willie Collum was within the thick of it on a day Gio van Bronckhorst's facet had been lowered to 9 males after each Alfredo Morelos and John Lundstram got their marching orders within the second half. And the Ibrox facet could not maintain on as Josh Campbell netted a last-gasp leveller.

The excessive drama within the second interval was a follow-on from two penalty selections the person within the center needed to make, with Rangers getting a spot kick after Rocky Bushiri grabbed Antonio Colak after the identical Hibs participant was denied one amid contact from James Tavernier on the different finish.

And what concerning the Jake Doyle-Hayes problem? Rangers boss van Bronckhorst cited that as he rued the "harsh" determination to provide Lundstram his marching orders. And the Dutchman had an ally in Hibs supervisor Lee Johnson, as he reckoned the Collum obtained that one mistaken.

On a pulsating day of motion, Sky Sports activities double act Kris Boyd and James McFadden plus Aiden McGeady debated the massive calls. BBC pundits Michael Stewart and Neil McCann additionally weighed in.

Bushiri's penalty enchantment

The primary large speaking level. Tavernier appeared to have maintain of the defender as Collum had view of the tangle within the field.

McGeady: "I feel it was a penalty. I feel in the event you simply take that incident on it is personal it is a penalty. I've seen them given and I've seen them not given so sadly we did not get the penalty after which Rangers go up the opposite finish and get one themselves."

McFadden: "Not if you'll be able to deal with every incident individually, which that ones simpler [Bushiri on Colak] as a result of Willie Collum is wanting straight at it. There's much less drive used from Rocky Bushiri than Tavernier makes use of. However in the event you give one you need to give the opposite. It's a penalty kick, it is loopy from Rocky Bushiri however I feel they had been lucky to get away with it earlier within the sport."

Jake Doyle-Hayes' reserving

The choice that turned a much bigger speaking level after the sport because of the name to ship Lundstram off (we'll get to that in a bit). The Irishman obtained a warning for hauling down Lundstram within the first interval.

McFadden: "It's a tactical foul, a cynical foul, each of them and that is the place the consistency you might be asking for comes. The distinction? The one distinction you'll be able to see is Lundstram lunges into it. Willie Collum's the mistaken facet. He possibly thinks there's extra drive in it however there isn't any drive for me."

Stewart: "I'll inform you what else; Jake Doyle-Hayes worn out John Lundstram within the first half with an analogous type of incident when Lundstram was driving ahead and he got here in from the facet with a scissors deal with which was arguably worse and he did not get despatched off."

Bushiri/Colak penalty award

Referee Willie Collum pointed to the spot after Rocky Bushiri seemed to have put his arms on Antonio Colak contained in the field. The ball had gone away from the pair and was trickling by to the toes of Hibs keeper David Marshall.

Boyd: "It is most likely epitomised the primary half. That battle between Antonio Colak and Rocky Bushiri. They've been shut collectively. They have been grabbing onto one another however I have no idea what is going on by Bushiri's thoughts there to drag Antonio Colak again. There is not any debate that it is a penalty, the subsequent debate is whether or not if it is a crimson card or not. The IFAB man is right here to clear all of it up."

McFadden : "He is pulled him again. You'll be able to't pull him and I feel it is only a response from Bushiri. It's extremely minimal contact, you'll be able to't be placing your arms round him and it is a penalty kick which is effectively dispatched by James Tavernier.

McGeady: "It's a penalty, sure. I am not fairly positive what Rocky's doing as a result of Colak is not getting any of the ball there. It is going safely again to Marsh. It is a bit of a blur, even Porto possibly enjoying the ball again to Marsh is not the very best cross however I am only a bit confused as to what Rocky was doing there.

Stewart: "You may say due to James Tavernier's penalty. I imply it is due to Rocky Bushiri. It is an absolute second of stupidity. Having stated all that I'm not satisfied it is a penalty. I do not assume from the viewing that I've had. I am not satisfied there's sufficient of a pull. I am not even positive if there's a pull. I simply assume he places two arms on him, which is simply loopy."

Lundstram crimson card

On a day of contentious points, the decision to ship the Scouser for an early bathtub for a cynical deal with on Martin Boyle was met with fierce debate from punters, each managers and the pundits.

Stewart: "The sending off of Lundstram is simply, once more it is one other one the place the truth that he has given a crimson card folks can begin to debate if he is lunged in."

Boyd: "I feel that one from Doyle-Hayes is definitely worse than the Lundstram one. From that angle that one appears to be like worse."

Morelos crimson card

Maybe the incident met with least resistance, other than commentator Andy Walker who claimed Collum obtained it mistaken after Morelos caught Marijan Cabraja with a swinging blow within the face.

Stewart: "Alfredo Morelos' sending off - that's the one Willie Collum has obtained proper. There is not any query. Absolute insanity. It is a crimson card all day lengthy and that is one which Willie Collum did get proper."

McCann: "Morelos is smiling away. I do not know what he is smiling about if he is elbowed the boy within the face as a result of it is loopy. Porteous and Bushiri are on yellows, I believed Morelos may ruffle their feathers. A straight crimson for Morelos is ridiculous. He is let his facet down massively."

READ NEXT

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post