Calls for Holyrood action over 'unhealthy monopoly' at Scotland's ports

Nearly all of Scotland’s ports are owned by international pension funds or tax-exile billionaires.

A Sunday Mail investigation has revealed the services at Grangemouth, Leith, Rosyth, Methil and Burntisland, and Dundee are owned by the Canadian authorities’s pension fund, which made an astonishing £18 billion final yr.

The important thing infrastructure belongings helped the Public Sector Pension Funding (PSP) board, which owns Forth Ports, to rocket in worth by greater than 18 per cent.

CEO Neil Cunningham boasted that his workforce delivered the “strongest absolute return in over 10 years via exceptionally turbulent occasions”.

In the meantime, on the west coast, Peel Ports – a agency managed by billionaire tax exile John Whittaker – owns greater than 450 sq. miles of the Clyde together with docks, shipyards and the waterways.

A rig (Rowan - Norway) sits at the docks in Dundee, whilst undergoing works before heading out to the North Sea
A rig (Rowan - Norway) sits on the docks in Dundee, while present process works earlier than heading out to the North Sea (Picture: Body Focus Seize Pictures / Alamy Inventory Photograph)

The agency reported revenues of £505million in 2021, and has boasted of ever-increasing earnings for the final 10 years operating.

Peel took management of the Clyde within the early 90s however has been accused of operating down its yards in favour of its shipbuilding subsidiary Cammell Laird at Birkenhead, on Merseyside.

Questions have additionally been raised over PSP’s possession of the port of Tilbury, on the Thames in London, which carries extra visitors than all of its websites on Scotland’s east coast mixed.

Campaigners and politicians have reacted with fury to the large income falling into personal fingers.

Former Scottish justice secretary Kenny MacAskill has demanded an finish to an “unhealthy monopoly” and known as for obligatory purchases by the Scottish Authorities.

In the meantime Paul Sweeney, Labour MSP for Glasgow, known as our findings a “kick within the tooth” for hard-up households.

He mentioned: “The revelation that the Canadian authorities’s personal pension fund, which owns a majority share of Forth Ports – and due to this fact runs most of Scotland’s east coast ports – made £18billion final yr is galling.

“It's a kick within the tooth to communities throughout Scotland who're on the sharp finish of the cost-of-living disaster.

“We all know the broader financial advantages that industrial prosperity can carry however at present we're receiving no profit by any means from these port belongings as a result of the income are being siphoned off to a authorities pension fund in Canada.

“That despair is compounded when you think about that Peel Ports owns many of the ports on the west coast and for a few years have pursued a method to ­intentionally stifle the potential of the Clyde.

Former justice secretary Kenny MacAskill.
Former justice secretary Kenny MacAskill. (Picture: © Michael McGurk 2017)

“It's not being allowed to flourish as a result of Peel is channelling funding into its competing west coast port on Merseyside, together with its Birkenhead shipbuilding subsidiary Cammell Laird.

“It's insupportable that Scotland – as soon as the envy of the world for its shipbuilding expertise – is being held again on this manner, and prime land that might be dwelling to the inexperienced marine industries of the long run is being rendered incapable by rivals having management over its future.

“Glasgow, and most of the areas within the neighborhood of the east coast ports like Leith and Grangemouth, are former industrial heartlands which undergo from horrifying ranges of poverty.

“If we now have any intention of addressing poverty ranges via reindustrialising our financial system, we should be severe about ­offering younger folks with the alternatives former generations had.”

Signal as much as our Politics e-newsletter

Get all the highest Scottish politics information despatched straight to your Inbox by signing as much as our Politics e-newsletter.

We cowl Holyrood, Westminster and native councils, with a present concentrate on how our governments are dealing with the coronavirus pandemic.

To enroll, merely enter your e mail deal with into the pink field close to the highest of this text.

Alternatively, you possibly can go to our e-newsletter signal up-centre. As soon as you're there, enter your e mail deal with and choose Politics and another Every day File newsletters which can be of curiosity.

On the River Clyde, ports in Glasgow, Greenock in addition to Hunterston and belongings in Ardrossan, Ayrshire, coast are owned and operated by Peel Ports.

There was livid criticism of the corporate over allegations it has actively blocked makes an attempt to develop Inchgreen Drydock in Greenock and different websites.

Regardless of being one of many largest services on the planet, the dock has been derelict for many years and big cranes which allowed ships to be serviced have been eliminated.

MacAskill has known as for all ports to be compulsorily bought and introduced again into public fingers.

He mentioned: “Each Forth Ports PLC and Clydeport are owned and operated for personal revenue, and the place the desires of different
communities, even international locations, dominate. This has created a monopoly state of affairs and one which I imagine is dangerous to native wants and Scotland’s nationwide pursuits.

Leith Docks
Leith Docks

“Ports are vital for our communities and to our financial system. Key harbours and estuaries are important for commerce, tourism and work.

“But in Scotland the 2 main firths have homeowners whose pursuits aren’t these of the native communities or the nation.

"Certainly, homeowners’ operations truly battle with the wants and desires of the Forth and Clyde.

“That is an unhealthy monopoly and it's damaging Scottish pursuits.

“It ought to be damaged up with the Authorities in search of motion from the Competitors and Mergers Authority to make sure Scotland’s pursuits are each protected and promoted.

“If not then obligatory buy or the creation of latest ports ought to be pursued by the Scottish Authorities.”

Robert Buirds, of the Marketing campaign to Save Inchgreen Drydock, added: “Regardless of years of guarantees Inchgreen has by no means been allowed to flourish and Peel Ports seem to not need different operators to utilise the important thing asset.”

A spokesman for Peel Ports insisted that it had pumped thousands and thousands into its Scottish belongings.

And the Scottish Authorities has dismissed requires it to compulsorily buy any ports and docks.

Ministers are already going through livid criticism over their nationalisation of the Ferguson Marine shipyard, which has didn't ship two CalMac ferries.

Grangemouth container terminal
Grangemouth container terminal

A Peel spokesman mentioned: “We’ve invested multi-millions of kilos into numerous operations on the west coast, offering ­a whole bunch of direct and oblique jobs for Scotland over a few years.

“From the cruise services on the Ocean Terminal in Greenock to formidable plans for the previous coal port at Hunterston, which has the potential to help many extra 1000's of jobs, our intentions are absolutely aligned with Scotland’s financial technique.

“We’re proud that our services proceed to create alternatives for funding, jobs and expertise that may profit the folks and
companies of Scotland for years to return, particularly in progress sectors comparable to renewables.”

A Scottish Authorities spokeswoman added: “They're a profitable mixture of privately owned, unbiased belief ports or publicly owned.

“There isn't any proof of monopoly practices being pursued by Scotland’s bigger ports and there are not any plans for obligatory buy.

“The message that will ship to potential buyers in ports and Scotland’s different necessary industries can be stark and unwelcome.”

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post