The general public inquiry into man who died in police custody is looking for a ban on prosecuting officers utilizing the proof they provide at its hearings.
The inquiry is being held into the 2015 loss of life of Sheku Bayoh after he was restrained by officers responding to a name in Kirkcaldy, Fife.
Its chairman Lord Bracadale issued his ruling on Tuesday confirming he'll request undertakings from the Solicitor Normal and Deputy Chief Constable of Police Scotland.
The undertakings would imply testimony given by cops couldn’t be used towards them in any future trial.
They'd additionally cowl any disciplinary proceedings launched towards them inside the pressure.
Lord Bracadale mentioned the transfer would permit key witnesses to offer “full and frank” proof.
However the Bayoh household, who opposed the undertakings, mentioned they had been “bitterly dissatisfied”.
Aamer Anwar, the household’s solicitor, mentioned: “Regardless of what's said by Lord Bracadale, the household utterly perceive what's sought by these performing for the cops they usually say this as a requirement for a convoluted type of immunity.”
A listening to final week noticed attorneys representing officers within the case argue undertakings must be sought.
In his ruling, Lord Bracadale made clear he wasn’t asking for “immunity” on behalf of any officer or former officer.
He mentioned: “It's vitally essential that each one ought to perceive the restricted nature of the undertakings which I request.
“The requests don't search immunity from prosecution or disciplinary proceedings.
“Within the occasion that new proof towards officer A emerges within the inquiry it is going to be open to the Solicitor Normal and the Deputy Chief Constable to utilize that materials as they assume match.
“The enterprise is restricted solely to using proof offered to the inquiry by officer A.”
Undertakings of this type have been given in different public inquiries, together with these probing the homicide of Stephen Lawrence, Bloody Sunday, and the Grenfell Tower hearth.
In Scots regulation, a witness is entitled to refuse to reply a query if a truthful reply may result in self-incrimination. This privilege can be enshrined within the European Conference of Human Rights.
Bayoh, 32, initially from Sierra Leone, died after being restrained by as much as 9 cops who used CS spray, pepper spray and batons.
Lord Bracadale mentioned the inquiry would require entry to full proof from “essential” witnesses to fulfil its phrases of reference.
He added: “I've repeatedly confused the essential public curiosity in striving to determine the reality within the Sheku Bayoh Inquiry.
“My activity is to seek for the reality by way of the proof. That may contain a consideration of the entire proof, making of findings in truth and drawing inferences from proved details.
“Every of the officers and former officers is an important witness in respect of extremely essential and probably controversial points of the phrases of reference.
“The train of the fitting towards self-incrimination by these witnesses can be prone to have a profound impact on my capability to achieve the reality of what occurred.”
In reaching his resolution to use for undertakings, Lord Bracadale mentioned the Bayoh household ought to hear the “fullest account” of occasions.
He mentioned: “I've dedicated to make sure that the household of Sheku Bayoh are on the coronary heart of this inquiry. They've a robust curiosity in listening to the fullest account of what occurred on Might 3 2015 resulting in the loss of life of Sheku Bayoh.
“The complete proof of the important thing witnesses is important to reaching that. Within the absence of the undertakings the household are impossible to listen to the total proof of the officers.
“The phrases of reference require me to carry particular person officers accountable for his or her actions.
“In an effort to try this I'll require the total and frank proof of officers and former officers to be accessible to the inquiry.
“With out the undertakings my capability to carry people to account might be severely restricted.”
The Bayoh household spoke out towards the ruling after assembly with Chief Constable Iain Livingstone and Deputy Chief Constable Fiona Taylor on Tuesday afternoon.
Mr Anwar mentioned the chief constable once more “expressed his honest private condolences to the household, and people of the service”.
He added: “Importantly he undertook that Police Scotland will take part absolutely within the public inquiry in an open and clear method.”
The general public inquiry, which is able to contemplate whether or not race performed an element in Bayoh’s loss of life, is because of start in Might.
Do not miss the newest information from round Scotland and past - Signal as much as our day by day e-newsletter right here.